Table of Contents

Protein Powder: 4 Honest Picks To Hit Your Daily Protein

Disclosure: Some of the links in this article are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, GymGuideHQ may earn from qualifying purchases. This comes at no extra cost to you and helps support our mission of creating honest fitness and wellness education. 

RAW Cookies N Cream and Isopure Clear Whey tubs next to a shaker with ice.

I struggle to get 200 grams of protein a day from food alone, and protein powder has been a huge help. I used to weigh over 230 pounds, and I’m working my way down to about 180 while keeping the muscle I’ve built. My nutritionist told me to stick with 200 grams, and eating that much food every day is hard.

If I want something refreshing, I’ll do the clear whey. If I want something sweet that tastes like dessert, I’ll do the cookies and cream with milk.

Everyone is different and has different numbers. But to reach my daily goal, protein powder has been the way.

Here are 4 options:

  • The two I drink.
  • One that two people close to me have used for over a year.
  • A ready-to-drink shake I researched but haven’t tried.

WHO It’s For

Woman doing a pull up at the gym.

This list is for anyone who struggles to get their protein from food alone. That might be you if you:

  • Lift or run and need more protein than your meals give you.
  • Are trying to lose fat without losing muscle.
  • Have a packed schedule and don’t always have time to cook.
  • Feel heavy after dairy and want a plant-based option.

It’s not for you if you already hit your number with food. You don’t need a shake just because everyone else has one. And if you have a health condition or follow a specific diet plan, check with your doctor or dietitian before adding protein powder.

WHAT I Looked At

Nutrition label on Isopure protein powder tub.

Here’s what I looked at for each one:

  • Protein type: what it’s made from.
  • Protein per serving: straight from the label.
  • How it sits and mixes: heavy or light, water or milk.
  • The brand: who’s behind it and how open they are about what’s inside. I passed on the cheapest tubs on purpose.

“Tested” means I drink it myself. “Researched” means I read the label and reviews but haven’t tried it. The plant-based one is researched, but two people close to me have used it for over a year.

WHY It Matters

When I was stuck in analysis paralysis starting my fitness journey, I watched and read a lot of fitness content. The one thing almost all of it agreed on was protein.

Once I started prioritizing it, I noticed a difference. I recover better, I’ve kept and built muscle, and I stay full longer, which makes it easier to stick to my diet. As long as I’m on top of my protein, I’m way more likely to hit my goals. That’s my experience, not a promise.

Alejandro lifting dumbbells at the gym.

Here’s what the research says:

  • Muscle: The International Society of Sports Nutrition recommends about 0.6 to 0.9 g of protein per pound of body weight a day for building or keeping muscle. Lifters cutting calories may need more, about 1 to 1.4 g.
  • Fullness: A 2015 review found higher-protein diets give a modest boost in fullness. In studies where people cut calories, they also lost more fat and kept more muscle. But feeling full didn’t mean eating less at the next meal, and long-term results came down to sticking with the diet.

Protein powder doesn’t replace real food. I still eat my meals and use shakes to fill the gap.

WHERE to Get It

Here’s where to find all four on Amazon:

RAW is my dessert shake, and Isopure is my refreshing one. The other two are for no dairy and no time.

WHEN to Use Each One

Quick comparison:

Product

Type

Protein

Mix with

Tag

RAW Cookies N Cream

Whey isolate

26g

Milk

Tested

Isopure Raspberry Island Tea

Clear whey

20g

Water + ice (60 mg caffeine)

Tested

Orgain Chocolate

Plant-based

21g

Water or milk

Researched

RAW Protein Shake, Mocha Latte

Ready-to-drink

30g

Nothing

Researched

Skim milk poured into a shaker with protein powder

Here’s when each one makes sense:

  • If you want something sweet, RAW Cookies N Cream (tested): I mix it with skim milk. With water, the aftertaste stays, and it’s not pleasant. With milk, it tastes like dessert. Just know the milk adds protein and calories on top of the label. Part of why I picked RAW is I’ve followed the people behind it, like Chris Bumstead, since 2021. I have no connection to them. I just buy it.
  • If you want something refreshing, Isopure Clear Whey (tested): I drink the Raspberry Island Tea with ice and a lot of water. It tastes like juice, not a shake, and I like getting more water in. Heads-up: it has 60 mg of caffeine per serving.
  • If dairy sits heavy for you, Orgain Vegan (researched): Two people close to me have used the chocolate for over a year. One drinks it with water or milk, and the other mixes it into their morning coffee for the flavor. The label says 2 scoops in 12 oz of water or plant-based milk.
  • If you don’t have time to mix, RAW Protein Shake (researched): It’s 30g of protein in a bottle, with nothing to shake. The Mocha Latte has coffee in it, so check the caffeine if you’re sensitive to it.

Final Word

Protein powder isn’t magic. For me, it’s been the way to hit 200 grams without eating all day. Pick the one you’ll actually drink, and start with the situation above that sounds most like you.

If you’re also trying to drink more water on long days, here’s how I use Cadence Hydration.

Cadence can in front of the Gym Guide HQ website. Sources

Jäger R, et al. International Society of Sports Nutrition Position Stand: protein and exercise. J Int Soc Sports Nutr. 2017;14:20.

Leidy HJ, et al. The role of protein in weight loss and maintenance. Am J Clin Nutr. 2015;101(6):1320S-1329S.

Supplement Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and is not intended as medical advice. Always consult with a qualified healthcare professional before starting any new supplement, especially if you have existing medical conditions or are taking medication.  

GGHQ

Your go-to fitness guide for every level—workouts, nutrition, and motivation to crush your goals